Skip to main content

Ribbon

  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Glossary
  • News & media
Fair Work Commission logo

Fair Work Commission

Australia's national workplace relations tribunal
Search is closed
Menu is closed

Search

Main menu

  • Awards & agreements
    • Minimum wages & conditions
    • Awards
    • Agreements
    • Legislation & regulations for awards & agreements
  • Cases, decisions & orders
    • Major cases
    • Summaries of significant decisions
    • Decisions by keywords
    • FWC Bulletin
    • Archived decisions & orders
    • Transcripts
    • Court reviews
    • Historical cases
  • Registered organisations
    • Fact sheets, templates & webinars
    • Find registered organisations
    • Find State-recognised associations
    • Registration
    • Running a registered organisation
    • Entry permits
    • Industrial action
    • Gazette notices
    • Lodgment
  • Resources
    • Online lodgment
    • Forms
    • Where to get legal help
    • Research
    • Workplace Relations Education Series
    • Benchbooks
    • Fact sheets, guides & videos
    • Practice notes
    • Resources in other languages
    • Case studies
    • Quarterly practitioner updates
    • Related sites
  • Termination of employment
    • Unfair dismissal
    • General protections dismissal
    • Unlawful termination
    • How the Commission works
  • Disputes at work
    • Fairness in the workplace
    • Resolving issues at the Commission
    • Cooperative Workplaces program
    • JobKeeper disputes
    • General protections (unlawful actions)
    • Anti-bullying
    • Industrial action
    • Awards & enterprise agreements disputes
    • Disputes about entry
    • How the Commission works
  • Home
  • Resources
  • Practice notes
Back to top

Practice note: Appeal proceedings

Print this page

 

Table of contents

On this page

  • Introduction
  • Application
  • Definitions
  • Overview
  • Legislation – Appeals
  • The appeal process
  • Lodging a notice of appeal
  • Representation
  • Stay orders
  • Appeal hearings
  • Standard directions for appeals
  • Conduct of appeal proceedings
  • Further information
  • Attachment 1 – Form of submissions (first page)

 

Introduction

  1. This Practice Note commenced on 11 April 2014.

Application

  1. The Practice Note applies to appeals lodged with the Fair Work Commission.

     
  2. The purpose of the Practice Note is to provide procedural guidance in relation to appeal proceedings. An Appeal Bench or the presiding member may vary the operation of the Practice Note by direction or order.

     
  3. The Practice Note is only intended to provide a general explanation of appeal rights and to set out the procedures followed by the Commission in the listing, hearing and determination of appeals. Appeal rights are provided under the Fair Work Act 2009. Before instituting an appeal, reference should be made to the relevant sections of the Act under which the appeal arises.

Definitions

  1. In this Practice Note:

    Act means the Fair Work Act 2009

    appellant means the person instituting the appeal

    Commission means the Fair Work Commission

    respondent means the other party to the original proceedings from which the appeal is brought

    Rules means the Fair Work Commission Rules 2013.

  2. A word or term used in this practice note has the same meaning as defined in the Act or in the Acts Interpretation Act 1901.

Overview

  1. The appeal process is a means of promoting consistent decision making; ensuring that decisions are made in accordance with the Act and to allow contentious matters to be tested.
     
  2. A person aggrieved by a decision of the Commission may seek permission to appeal against that decision.  The term ‘person aggrieved’ is capable of extending beyond persons whose legal interests are affected by the decision in question and extends to persons with an interest in the decision beyond that of an ordinary member of the public, such as a registered organisation.

    See Tweed Valley Fruit Processors Pty Ltd v Ross and Others (1996) 137 ALR 70; Australian Postal Corporation v Communications, Electrical, Electronic, Energy, Information, Postal, Plumbing and Allied Services Union of Australia [2009] FWAFB 599 and Australian Industry Group and Pacific Brands Limited t/a Dunlop Foams [2010] FWAFB 4337.

  1. An appeal may be instituted against a decision or order made by:
  • a single member of the Commission, or
  • the General Manager of the Commission (including a delegate of the General Manager) in matters concerning the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009.

Legislation – Appeals

  1. The following extracts from the Act are relevant.

Part 5-1 – Fair Work Commission

Division 3 – Conduct of matters before the FWC

Subdivision E – Appeals, reviews and referring questions of law

604 Appeal of decisions

(1) A person who is aggrieved by a decision:

(a) made by the FWC (other than a decision of a Full Bench or the Minimum Wage Panel); or

(b) made by the General Manager (including a delegate of the General Manager) under the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009;

may appeal the decision, with the permission of the FWC.

(2) Without limiting when the FWC may grant permission, the FWC must grant permission if the FWC is satisfied that it is in the public interest to do so.

Note: Subsection (2) does not apply in relation to an application for an unfair dismissal (see section 400).

(3) A person may appeal the decision by applying to the FWC.

Part 3-2 – Unfair dismissal

Division 5 – Procedural matters

400 Appeal rights

(1) Despite subsection 604(2), the FWC must not grant permission to appeal from a decision made by the FWC under this Part unless the FWC considers that it is in the public interest to do so.

(2) Despite subsection 604(1), an appeal from a decision made by the FWC in relation to a matter arising under this Part can only, to the extent that it is an appeal on a question of fact, be made on the ground that the decision involved a significant error of fact.

The appeal process

General

  1. The current appeal provisions in the Act are modelled on the appeal provisions contained in theWorkplace Relations Act 1996 and its predecessors, and the past jurisprudence in relation to appeals, in particular the decision of the High Court in Coal and Allied Operations Pty Ltd v Australian Industrial Relations Commission (2000) 203 CLR 194 remains relevant. There needs to be a legitimate reason for the appeal as the Full Bench may only exercise its powers if it identifies some error on the part of the primary decision-maker.
  1. Where the original decision has involved the exercise of a significant level of discretion it is not enough that the Full Bench would have reached a different conclusion. The Full Bench may only intervene on the limited ground that some error has been made in exercising the discretion. An illustrative list of such errors was set out in House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499 at 505, namely that the decision-maker has:
  • acted upon a wrong principle
  • been guided by irrelevant factors
  • mistaken the facts, or
  • failed to take some material consideration into account.

A further illustrative list of errors which may be made by a Tribunal is set out in Craig v The State of South Australia (1995) 184 CLR 163 and approved in Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf  (2001) 206 CLR 323 and Kirk v Industrial Relations Commission; Kirk Group Holdings Pty Ltd v WorkCover Authority of New South Wales (Inspector Childs) (2010) 239 CLR 531.

The Full Bench may also intervene on the basis that the decision subject to appeal is unreasonable or plainly unjust.

  1. In each appeal the Full Bench needs to determine two issues:

  • whether permission to appeal should be granted, and
  • whether there has been an error in the original decision.
  1. In considering whether permission to appeal should be granted, the Full Bench will consider whether it is in the public interest to grant permission to appeal. The ‘public interest’ is not defined in the Act, but it generally refers to a benefit or advantage to the whole community, as opposed to an individual. The task of assessing whether the public interest test is met is a discretionary one involving a broad value judgment. In GlaxoSmithKline Australia Pty Ltd v Makin [2010] FWAFB 5343 a Full Bench of the Tribunal identified some of the considerations that may attract the public interest:
     

    "... the public interest might be attracted where a matter raises issues of importance and general application, or where there is a diversity of decisions at first instance so that guidance from an appellate court is required, or where the decision at first instance manifests an injustice, or the result is counter intuitive or that the legal principles applied appear disharmonious when compared with other recent decisions dealing with similar matters ..."

  2. Subject to the appellant demonstrating an arguable case of appealable error, the Commission has a broad discretion as to the circumstances in which it can grant permission to appeal. Some examples of considerations which have traditionally been adopted in granting leave include:

  • that the decision is attended with sufficient doubt to warrant its reconsideration
  • that the Commission at first instance may have exceeded its jurisdiction, and
  • that substantial injustice may result if leave is refused.

CFMEU v AIRC 84 IR 314 at 333; Wan v AIRC 116 FCR 489; Wright v Australian Customs Service 120 IR 346.

Unfair dismissal appeals

  1. The general requirements relating to appeals are modified in the case of appeals against unfair dismissal decisions. If the error that is alleged is an error of fact, then the appellant must persuade the Full Bench that it is a significant error of fact [see s.400 of the Act]. Further, s.400(1) provides that permission to appeal from an unfair dismissal decision must not be made unless the Commission considers that it is in the public interest to do so.

     
  2. In Coal & Allied Mining Services Pty Ltd v Lawler and others, (2011) 192 FCR 78 at paragraph 43 Buchanan J (with whom Marshall and Cowdroy JJ agreed) characterised the test under s.400 as 'a stringent one'. The Tribunal must not grant permission to appeal unless it considers that it is 'in the public interest to do so'.

Lodging a notice of appeal

Form

  1. A party seeking to institute an appeal against a decision of a Commission Member (or a person exercising a delegation from the President or the General Manager) must do so by lodging a Notice of Appeal in accordance with Form F7.

Appeal books

  1. The appellant must also lodge three copies of an appeal book containing:
  • any order made by the Commission
  • the statement of the reasons for the decision
  • the transcript of the evidence and argument in the proceedings from which the appeal is brought, or the relevant extract from the transcript (it is the appellant’s responsibility to obtain a copy of the transcript for inclusion in the appeal book), and
  • each document that was an exhibit or written submission in the proceedings and relates to the grounds of appeal set out in the notice.

The appellant must number the pages of the appeal book.

The appeal book must be lodged within 7 days of the lodgment of the notice of appeal.

[See Rule 56(3)]

  1. The Commission may waive in whole or in part the requirement for the appellant to provide appeal books if the appellant makes a written request before the time at which the appellant is required to lodge the appeal books [see Rule 6].

Time limits

  1. The Notice of Appeal (Form F7) must be lodged with the Commission within 21 days after the date the decision being appealed was issued [see Rule 56(2)]. If a Notice of Appeal is lodged later than 21 days after the decision under appeal was issued, application should be made for an extension of time within which to institute the appeal. To do so the appellant needs to indicate this in the Notice of Appeal (Form F7) [see Rule 56(2)].
  1. Time limits of the kind in Rule 56(2) are not simply extended as a matter of course. There are sound administrative and industrial reasons for setting a limit to the time for bringing an appeal and the 21 day period specified in the rules will only be extended where there are good reasons for doing so. The following authorities indicate that the following matters are relevant to the exercise of the Tribunal’s discretion under Rule 56(2):
  • whether there is a satisfactory reason for the delay
  • the length of the delay
  • the nature of the grounds of appeal and the likelihood that one or more of those grounds being upheld if time was extended, and
  • any prejudice to the respondent if time were extended. 

Stevenson-Helmer v Epworth Hospital, Print T2277, 19 October 2000; SPC Ardmona Operations Ltd v Esam and Organ, (2005) 141 IR 338 and Tokoda v Westpac Banking Corporation, [2012] FWAFB 3995.

Service requirements

  1. On lodging a Notice of Appeal, the appellant should, as soon as practicable, serve a copy of the Notice of Appeal on the other parties to the proceedings from which the appeal is brought.

Representation

Self-representation

  1. The appellant or the respondent can represent themselves and are not required to be represented. However, depending on the complexity of the issues raised in the appeal it may be advisable to obtain professional advice or representation.

Lawyers and paid agents

  1. A person may be represented in a matter before the Commission (including by making an application or submission on behalf of the person) by a lawyer or paid agent only with the permission of the Commission [see s.596(1) of the Act].
  1. The Commission may grant permission for a person to be represented by a lawyer or paid agent in a matter if:
  • it would enable the matter to be dealt with more efficiently, taking into account the complexity of the matter
  • it would be unfair not to allow the person to be represented because the person is unable to represent themself effectively, or
  • it would be unfair not to allow the person to be represented taking into account fairness between the person and other parties to the matter.

[See s.596(2) of the Act]

  1. A person does not need to seek permission to be represented by:
  • an employee or officer of the person
  • an employee or officer of a registered organisation, association of employers or peak council, or
  • a bargaining representative.

[See s.596(3) of the Act]

Stay orders

  1. An application can be made to the Commission to stay all or part of a decision or order as part of an appeal [see s.606 of the Act]. To do so the appellant needs to indicate this in the Notice of Appeal (Form F7).

     
  2. An order staying the operation of all or part of the decision under appeal may be made by a Presidential Member of the Commission and will operate until a decision or further order is made by the Full Bench hearing the appeal. For example: if a Commission Member had awarded the payment of compensation a stay order may have the effect that payment would not be required until after the Full Bench determined the decision under appeal.

     
  3. If permission to appeal is refused or the appeal is dismissed then the stay order will be discharged and the amount of compensation originally ordered will have to be paid. A stay order may also be subject to certain conditions. For example, an order that a party pay an amount of compensation may be stayed provided that the amount of compensation is paid into an interest bearing account.

     
  4. Generally a hearing for a stay order will be listed within 7 days from the lodgment of the appeal.

     
  5. Some recent examples of appeals where stay orders have been granted are:

    Virgin Australia International Airlines Pty Ltd T/A Virgin Australia v David Taleski [2013] FWC 624 and GM Holden Ltd v Rodney Symonds, [2013] FWC 332.

Appeal hearings

Listing of appeals

  1. Generally an appeal will be listed for hearing within 12 weeks after the lodgment of the appeal.

     
  2. With the consent of the parties, an appeal may be conducted without holding a hearing if it appears to the Full Bench that the appeal can be adequately determined on the papers and without parties making oral submissions at a hearing [see s.607(1) of the Act].

Expedited appeals

  1. Where an application to appeal a decision of the Commission relates to a decision which ought be dealt with urgently, the appeal may be heard more quickly than if it were assigned to an appeal roster.

     
  2. Where a party to an appeal wishes to have their appeal heard urgently that party should request in writing that the appeal be expedited, preferably at the time of lodging the appeal, by completing question 6 in the Notice of Appeal (Form F7), or as soon as possible after the appeal has been lodged. Examples of applications to appeal which may need to be expedited include appeals of decisions that relate to protected industrial action and bargaining disputes, and other matters where time is of the essence.

Composition of Full Bench

  1. A Full Bench consists of at least three Commission Members, including at least one Presidential Member. Full Benches are constituted by the President [see s.618 of the Act].

Powers of Full Bench

  1. The Full Bench will normally deal with the appeal on the basis of the evidence in the proceedings which led to the decision subject to the appeal. However it may admit further evidence or take into account any other information or evidence where appropriate [see s.607(2) of the Act].
  2. The Act confers a discretion on a Full Bench hearing an appeal to admit further evidence and take into account any other information or evidence (s.607(2) of the Act). The principles established in Akins v National Australia Bank [1994] 34 NSWLR 155 at 160 are relevant to when the discretion to admit new evidence may be exercised. In that case the Court noted that while it is not possible to formulate a test which should be applied in every case, in general these three principles should be applied:

  • it must be shown that the evidence could not have been obtained with reasonable diligence for use at the proceedings at first instance
  • the evidence must be such that there must be a high degree of probability that there would be a different decision, and
  • the evidence must be credible. 
  1. In a number of Full Bench decisions, (including JJ Richards & Sons Pty Ltd v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia [2010] FWAFB 9963, and Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Mr John Crema, Mr Paul Edwards, Ms Christine Comley and Mr Ray Allan [2012] FWAFB 8453), the Commission has observed that the principles governing the admission of fresh evidence on appeal in the Court provide a useful guide to the exercise of the Commission’s discretion in s.607(2) of the Act.

     
  2. The Full Bench may do any of the following in relation to the appeal:
  • confirm, quash or vary the decision
  • make a further decision in relation to the matter that is the subject of the appeal
  • refer the matter that is the subject of the appeal to a Commission Member for further action. 

[See s.607(3) of the Act]

Making decisions

  1. A decision of a majority of the members on the Full Bench prevails; however, if there is no majority, the decision of the Commission Member who has seniority prevails [see s.618 (3)–(4) of the Act].

Adjournments

  1. A Full Bench appeal roster has been instituted in order to ensure that appeals are heard in a timely fashion. For this reason, adjournments will rarely be granted.

     
  2. Any request for an adjournment of an appeal should be made as soon as possible after a party receives the Notice of Listing of the appeal.  The request should be made to the presiding Member of the Full Bench. The request should be in writing and provide a full explanation as to why the adjournment is sought.

     
  3. A copy of the adjournment request should also be sent to any other party to the appeal.

Standard directions for appeals

Direction to file written submissions

  1. Once a date is fixed for the hearing of an appeal the appellant and the respondent will be directed to file and serve outlines of submissions or witness statements that might be presented on appeal, on or before particular dates prior to that hearing.

Format of submissions

  1. The first page of a submission that is lodged with the Commission must be headed in the manner set out in Attachment 1 (Word).

  2. Generally, outlines of submissions should:

  • clearly identify the grounds on which permission to appeal is sought and identify the legal or factual errors in the decision
  • list any authorities upon which you wish to rely
  • in the case of unfair dismissal decisions, the appellant must clearly identify why it is in the public interest to grant permission to appeal and identify any significant error(s) of fact in the decision subject to appeal
  • be generally limited to less than 10 pages
  • be produced on A4 size paper, and
  • have type which is double spaced.
  1. Each party must lodge their outline of submissions with the Commission either:
  • by email to the chambers email listed on the notice of listing, or
  • in person or by post, in which case, they must lodge 3 copies of the outline of submissions in hard copy.

A copy of the outline must also be served on the other parties to the appeal.

Note: In circumstances where an appeal deals with complex issues of law or fact the appellant may apply to vary the standard directions in the notice of appeal. Where the respondent seeks to vary the standard directions they may apply in writing as soon as possible after being notified of the appeal.

Filing dates

  1. Generally, the appellant’s outline of submissions will be required to be filed with the Commission at least 8 weeks before the scheduled hearing date and the respondent’s outline will be required to be filed at least 5 weeks before the hearing date. The following chart provides a general outline of the common timing of the appeal process:
up arrow
 
12 weeks
 
down arrow

Appeal lodged

down arrow

1 week

Notice of listing/directions issued and appellant to lodge appeal books

down arrow

3 weeks

Appellant's outline of submission filed

down arrow

3 weeks

Respondent's outline of submissions filed

down arrow

5 weeks

Hearing

Other directions

  1. The Full Bench assigned to hear an appeal may make further directions regarding the filing of submissions or materials in relation to the appeal and may vary the standard directions set out above.

Conduct of appeal proceedings

  1. Generally the hearing of an appeal proceeds in the following way: the appellant is given an opportunity to present its case on appeal; the respondent is given an opportunity to respond to that case; and the appellant is then given an opportunity to reply to the respondent’s case.

     
  2. Where a Full Bench has allowed the admission of further evidence in an appeal, the Full Bench may determine that the evidence from the appellant and the respondent should be presented before hearing the submissions of the parties.

     
  3. At the conclusion of the proceedings, the Full Bench will either deliver its decision in the appeal or announce that the decision is reserved. Where a decision is reserved, it will generally be given in writing and within 8–12 weeks of the final hearing day or the day on which any further submissions or materials are required to be filed by the parties.

Further information

  1. For further information refer to:

  • the Fair Work Commission Rules 2013, and
  • the Full Bench decisions search on the Commission’s website.

Attachment 1 – Form of submissions (first page)

  • Appeal proceedings attachment 1 – Form of submissions (Word)

Updated time

Last updated

01 August 2019

 

Bookmark/Search this post

Facebook logo Google+ logo Twitter logo

Page feedback

Did you find what you were looking for?

Please note: If you would like a response to your question, please contact us or lodge a complaint. This feedback is only about content on this page and will be used to improve website usability. The comments are not monitored for personal information or workplace complaints. 

Main menu

  • Awards & agreements
    • Minimum wages & conditions
      • National employment standards
      • National minimum wage orders
      • Annual wage reviews
        • Annual Wage Review 2020–21
          • Decisions & statements
          • Research
          • Correspondence
          • Statistical reporting
          • Timetable
        • Annual Wage Review 2019–20
          • Decisions & statements
          • Determinations
          • National Minimum Wage Order 2020
          • Additional material
          • Consultations
          • Junior & apprentice rates in modern awards
          • Notices of listing
          • Research
            • Research proposals
          • Statistical reporting
          • Correspondence
          • Submissions
            • Initial submissions
            • Submissions in reply
            • Supplementary submissions
          • Timetable
          • Transcripts
        • Annual Wage Review 2018–19
          • Decisions & statements
          • Determinations
          • National Minimum Wage Order 2019
          • Notices of listing
          • Research
          • Statistical reporting
          • Additional material
          • Correspondence
          • Submissions
            • Initial submissions
            • Submissions in reply
          • Timetable
          • Consultations
          • Transcripts
        • Annual Wage Review 2017–18
          • Decisions & statements
          • Determinations
          • National Minimum Wage Order 2018
          • Notices of listing
          • Research
            • Research proposals
          • Statistical reporting
          • Correspondence
          • Submissions
            • Initial submissions
            • Submissions in reply
            • Post-budget submissions
          • Timetable
          • Consultations
          • Transcripts
        • Annual Wage Review 2016–17
          • Decisions & statements
          • Determinations
          • National Minimum Wage Order 2017
          • Notices of listing
          • Research
            • Research proposals
          • Statistical reporting
          • Additional material
          • Correspondence
          • Submissions
            • Initial submissions
            • Submissions in reply
            • Post-budget submissions
          • Timetable
          • Consultations
          • Transcripts
        • Annual Wage Review 2015–16
          • Decisions & statements
          • Determinations
          • National Minimum Wage Order 2016
          • Notices of listing
          • Research
          • Statistical reporting
          • Additional material
          • Correspondence
          • Submissions
            • Initial submissions
            • Submissions in reply
            • Post-budget submissions
          • Timetable
          • Consultations
          • Transcript
        • Annual Wage Review 2014–15
          • Decisions & statements
          • Determinations
          • National Minimum Wage Order 2015
          • Notices of listing
          • Research
            • Research proposals
          • Statistical reporting
          • Additional information
          • Correspondence
          • Submissions
            • Initial submissions
            • Post-budget submissions
            • Submissions in reply
          • Timetable
          • Consultations
          • Transcript
        • Annual Wage Review 2013–14
          • Decisions & statements
          • Determinations
          • National Minimum Wage Order 2014
          • Notices of listing
          • Research
            • Research proposals
          • Statistical reporting
          • Correspondence
          • Submissions
            • Initial submissions
            • Submissions in reply
            • Post-budget submissions
          • Timetable
          • Consultations
          • Transcript
          • Award variations arising from 2013-14 review
        • Annual Wage Review 2012–13
          • Decisions & statements
          • Determinations
          • National Minimum Wage Order 2013
          • Notices of listing
          • Research
            • Research proposals
            • Spreadsheets with ANZSIC classes & mapped modern awards
            • Spreadsheets with modern awards & relevant ANZSIC classes listed
          • Statistical reporting
          • Correspondence
          • Submissions
            • Initial submissions
            • Submissions in reply
            • Post-budget submissions
          • Timetable
          • Consultations
          • Transcript
        • Annual Wage Review 2011–12
          • Decisions & statements
          • Determinations
          • National Minimum Wage Order 2012
          • Notices of listing
          • Research
          • Assessing the needs of the low paid
          • Additional material
          • Correspondence
          • Submissions
            • Initial submissions
            • Submissions in reply
            • Post-budget submissions
          • Timetable
          • Transcript
        • Annual Wage Review 2010–11
          • Decisions & statements
          • Determinations
          • National Minimum Wage Order 2011
          • Notices of listing
          • Research
            • Appendices – Research Report 6/2011
            • Research proposals
          • Juniors, apprentices & trainees materials
          • Statistical reporting
          • Correspondence
          • Submissions
          • Timetable
          • Transcript
        • Annual Wage Review 2009–10
          • Decisions & statements
          • Determinations
          • National Minimum Wage Order 2010
          • Transitional instruments
          • Notices of listing
          • Research
          • Additional material
          • Submissions
          • Timetable
          • Consultation
          • Transcript
        • AFPC & AIRC reviews
          • AFPC 2009 Wage-Setting Review
          • AFPC 2008 Wage-Setting Review
          • AFPC 2007 Wage-Setting Review
          • AFPC 2006 Wage-Setting Review
          • AFPC – Employees with disability in open employment decisions
          • AFPC – Employees with disability in Australian Disability Enterprises decisions
          • AFPC – Drought deferral decision
          • AFPC – Real estate decision
        • Legislation
        • Subscribe
    • Awards
      • Modern award reviews
        • 4 yearly review
          • AM2014/1 – Initial stage proceedings
          • AM2019/17 – Final stage proceedings
          • Alleged NES inconsistencies
          • Award stage overview
          • Awards under review
          • Common issues
            • AM2016/35 – Abandonment of employment
            • AM2014/47 – Annual leave
            • AM2016/13 – Annualised salaries
            • AM2014/192 – Apprentice conditions
            • AM2014/300 – Award flexibility
            • AM2016/36 – Blood donor leave
            • AM2014/197 – Casual employment
            • AM2015/1 – Family & domestic violence clause
            • AM2015/2 – Family friendly work arrangements
            • AM2014/306 – Micro business schedule
            • AM2016/17 – National Training Wage
            • AM2017/51 – Overtime for casuals
            • AM2014/196 – Part-time employment
            • AM2016/8 – Payment of wages
            • AM2014/301 – Public holidays
            • AM2014/190 – Transitional provisions
          • Decisions & statements
          • Timetable
          • Plain language re-drafting
            • All documents
            • Awards under review
            • Other matters
            • Guidelines & pilot
        • Penalty rates case
          • Award specific matters
            • AM2017/39 – Clubs Award and Hospitality Award
            • AM2017/40 – Hair and Beauty Award
            • AM2017/42 – Restaurant Award
            • AM2017/43 – General Retail Award
          • About the penalty rates case
          • AM2014/305 – All documents
          • AM2014/305 – Correspondence
          • AM2014/305 – Decisions & statements
          • AM2014/305 – Determinations & orders
          • AM2014/305 – Evidence & witness statements
          • AM2014/305 – Exhibits
          • AM2014/305 – Notices of listing & directions
          • AM2014/305 – Research
          • AM2014/305 – Submissions
          • AM2014/305 – Transcript
          • AM2014/305 – Timetable
        • Superannuation fund reviews
          • Overview
            • Default superannuation list
            • Schedule of Approved Employer MySuper Products
            • Varying modern award default fund terms
            • Submissions & correspondence – 2013 review
          • Applications
          • Determinations
          • Submissions on applications
          • Decisions & statements
          • Submissions & correspondence
          • Notices of listing & directions
          • Transcript
          • Timetable
          • Relevant legislation
        • Modern awards review 2012
          • Notices of listing & directions
          • Transcript
          • Decisions & statements
          • Modern awards under review
            • Multiple awards & Full bench matters
            • Draft allowances sheets
      • Modern awards
        • Modern awards list
        • Modern awards pay database
          • Glossary
        • Modern awards fact sheets
          • Annual leave in advance
          • Cashing out of annual leave
          • EFT payment of annual leave
          • Excessive annual leave accruals
      • Make or vary an award
        • Variation applications
      • Interpret or enforce an award
        • How to read a consolidated modern award
        • How to read a consolidated award
      • Award modernisation
        • About modern awards
        • About award modernisation
        • Enterprise award applications
        • Variation applications
        • Termination of instruments
        • Division 2B State awards
        • State reference public sector transitional award applications
      • Awards research
    • Agreements
      • Finding agreements
      • Making an agreement
        • Step 1: Before you start bargaining
        • Step 2: Start bargaining
        • Step 3: Developing the terms of the agreement
        • Step 4: Finalising the agreement
        • Step 5: Explaining the agreement to employees
        • Step 6: Preparing for the vote
        • Step 7: Conducting the vote
        • Step 8: Filling in your application
        • Step 9: Lodging your application
        • Step 10: Approving your application
      • Approval process
        • Undertakings in enterprise agreements
      • Agreements in progress
      • Vary an agreement
      • Terminate an agreement
        • Terminating individual agreements
      • Agreement resources
        • Single enterprise agreement date calculator
        • Guide – Notice of employee representational rights
        • Types of agreements
        • Interpreting or enforcing an agreement
        • About enterprise bargaining
          • Bargaining disputes
    • Legislation & regulations for awards & agreements
  • Cases, decisions & orders
    • Major cases
      • Annual Wage Review 2019–20
      • Plain language re-drafting
      • Undergraduate qualifications review
      • Review of certain C14 rates in modern awards
      • Equal Remuneration and Work Value Case
        • Applications
        • Decisions & statements
        • Orders
        • Timetable
        • Submissions
        • Correspondence
        • Notices of listing & directions
        • Papers
        • Transcript
        • Legislation
      • United Voice & National Union of Workers proposed amalgamation
      • Application to terminate IPCA Enterprise Agreement 2013
      • Application to terminate IPCA (SA) Enterprise Agreement 2011
      • Application to terminate IPCA (NSW) Enterprise Agreement 2011
      • Application to terminate IPCA (QLD) Enterprise Agreement 2011
      • Clerks Award – COVID-19
      • Vary an enterprise agreement – COVID-19
      • Health sector awards – pandemic leave
        • Applications
        • Notices of listing & directions
        • Decisions & statements
        • Determinations
        • Orders
        • Submissions & witness statements
        • Correspondence
        • Transcript
        • Information notes & articles
      • Clerks - Private Sector Award 2020 - Work from home case
      • Work Value Case – Aged Care Award
      • Award flexibility – Hospitality and retail sectors
    • Summaries of significant decisions
      • National wage & safety net review decisions
    • Decisions by keywords
    • FWC Bulletin
      • FWC Bulletin 2020
      • FWC Bulletin 2019
      • FWC Bulletin 2018
      • FWC Bulletin 2017
      • FWC Bulletin 2016
      • FWC Bulletin 2015
      • FWC Bulletin 2014
      • FWC Bulletin 2013
      • FWC Bulletin 2012
      • FWC Bulletin 2011
      • FWC Bulletin 2010
      • FWC Bulletin 2009
      • FWC Bulletin 2008
      • FWC Bulletin 2007
      • FWC Bulletin 2006
      • FWC Bulletin 2005
      • FWC Bulletin 2004
      • FWC Bulletin 2003
      • FWC Bulletin 2002
      • FWC Bulletin 2001
      • FWC Bulletin 2000 and previous
    • Archived decisions & orders
      • All decisions
        • All decisions 2013
        • All decisions 2012
        • All decisions 2011
        • All decisions 2010
        • All decisions 2009
        • All decisions 2008
        • All decisions 2007
        • All decisions 2006
        • All decisions 2005
        • All decisions 2004
        • All decisions 2003
        • All decisions 2002
        • All decisions 2001
        • All decisions 2000
      • Full bench decisions
        • Full bench decisions 2013
        • Full bench decisions 2012
        • Full bench decisions 2011
        • Full bench decisions 2010
        • Full bench decisions 2009
        • Full bench decisions 2008
        • Full bench decisions 2007
        • Full bench decisions 2006
        • Full bench decisions 2005
        • Full bench decisions 2004
        • Full bench decisions 2003
        • Full bench decisions 2002
        • Full bench decisions 2001
        • Full bench decisions 2000
      • Enterprise agreement decisions
        • Enterprise agreement decisions 2013
        • Enterprise agreement decisions 2012
        • Enterprise agreement decisions 2011
        • Enterprise agreement decisions 2010
        • Enterprise agreement decisions 2009
      • General Manager & Delegates' decisions
        • General Manager & Delegates' decisions 2013
        • General Manager & Delegates' decisions 2012
        • General Manager & Delegates' decisions 2011
        • General Manager & Delegates' decisions 2010
        • General Manager & Delegates' decisions 2009
        • General Manager & Delegates' decisions 2008
        • General Manager & Delegates' decisions 2007
        • General Manager & Delegates' decisions 2006
        • General Manager & Delegates' decisions 2005
        • General Manager & Delegates' decisions 2004
        • General Manager & Delegates' decisions 2003
        • General Manager & Delegates' decisions 2002
        • General Manager & Delegates' decisions 2001
      • Orders & determinations
        • Orders & determinations 2013
        • Orders & determinations 2012
        • Orders & determinations 2011
        • Orders & determinations 2010
        • Orders & determinations 2009
        • Orders & determinations 2008
        • Orders & determinations 2007
        • Orders & determinations 2006
        • Orders & determinations 2005
        • Orders & determinations 2004
        • Orders & determinations 2003
        • Orders & determinations 2002
        • Orders & determinations 2001
        • Orders & determinations 2000
    • Transcripts
      • 2021 transcripts
        • 2021 January transcripts
        • 2021 February transcripts
      • 2020 transcripts
        • 2020 January transcripts
        • 2020 February transcripts
        • 2020 March transcripts
        • 2020 April transcripts
        • 2020 May transcripts
        • 2020 June transcripts
        • 2020 July transcripts
        • 2020 August transcripts
        • 2020 September transcripts
        • 2020 October transcripts
        • 2020 November transcripts
        • 2020 December transcripts
      • 2019 transcripts
        • 2019 January transcripts
        • 2019 February transcripts
        • 2019 March transcripts
        • 2019 April transcripts
        • 2019 May transcripts
        • 2019 June transcripts
        • 2019 July transcripts
        • 2019 August transcripts
        • 2019 September transcripts
        • 2019 October transcripts
        • 2019 November transcripts
        • 2019 December transcripts
      • 2018 transcripts
        • 2018 January transcripts
        • 2018 February transcripts
        • 2018 March transcripts
        • 2018 April transcripts
        • 2018 May transcripts
        • 2018 June transcripts
        • 2018 July transcripts
        • 2018 August transcripts
        • 2018 September transcripts
        • 2018 October transcripts
        • 2018 November transcripts
        • 2018 December transcripts
      • 2017 transcripts
        • 2017 January transcripts
        • 2017 February transcripts
        • 2017 March transcripts
        • 2017 April transcripts
        • 2017 May transcripts
        • 2017 June transcripts
        • 2017 July transcripts
        • 2017 August transcripts
        • 2017 September transcripts
        • 2017 October transcripts
        • 2017 November transcripts
        • 2017 December transcripts
      • 2016 transcripts
        • 2016 January transcripts
        • 2016 February transcripts
        • 2016 March transcripts
        • 2016 April transcripts
        • 2016 May transcripts
        • 2016 June transcripts
        • 2016 July transcripts
        • 2016 August transcripts
        • 2016 September transcripts
        • 2016 October transcripts
        • 2016 November transcripts
        • 2016 December transcripts
      • 2015 transcripts
        • 2015 January transcripts
        • 2015 February transcripts
        • 2015 March transcripts
        • 2015 April transcripts
        • 2015 May transcripts
        • 2015 June transcripts
        • 2015 July transcripts
        • 2015 August transcripts
        • 2015 September transcripts
        • 2015 October transcripts
        • 2015 November transcripts
        • 2015 December transcripts
      • 2014 transcripts
        • 2014 January transcripts
        • 2014 February transcripts
        • 2014 March transcripts
        • 2014 April transcripts
        • 2014 May transcripts
        • 2014 June transcripts
        • 2014 July transcripts
        • 2014 August transcripts
        • 2014 September transcripts
        • 2014 October transcripts
        • 2014 November transcripts
        • 2014 December transcripts
      • 2013 transcripts
        • 2013 January transcripts
        • 2013 February transcripts
        • 2013 March transcripts
        • 2013 April transcripts
        • 2013 May transcripts
        • 2013 June transcripts
        • 2013 July transcripts
        • 2013 August transcripts
        • 2013 September transcripts
        • 2013 October transcripts
        • 2013 November transcripts
        • 2013 December transcripts
      • 2012 transcripts
        • 2012 January transcripts
        • 2012 February transcripts
        • 2012 March transcripts
        • 2012 April transcripts
        • 2012 May transcripts
        • 2012 June transcripts
        • 2012 July transcripts
        • 2012 August transcripts
        • 2012 September transcripts
        • 2012 October transcripts
        • 2012 November transcripts
        • 2012 December transcripts
      • 2011 transcripts
        • 2011 January transcripts
        • 2011 February transcripts
        • 2011 March transcripts
        • 2011 April transcripts
        • 2011 May transcripts
        • 2011 June transcripts
        • 2011 July transcripts
        • 2011 August transcripts
        • 2011 September transcripts
        • 2011 October transcripts
        • 2011 November transcripts
        • 2011 December transcripts
      • 2010 transcripts
        • 2010 January transcripts
        • 2010 February transcripts
        • 2010 March transcripts
        • 2010 April transcripts
        • 2010 May transcripts
        • 2010 June transcripts
        • 2010 July transcripts
        • 2010 August transcripts
        • 2010 September transcripts
        • 2010 October transcripts
        • 2010 November transcripts
        • 2010 December transcripts
      • 2009 transcripts
        • 2009 January transcripts
        • 2009 February transcripts
        • 2009 March transcripts
        • 2009 April transcripts
        • 2009 May transcripts
        • 2009 June transcripts
        • 2009 July transcripts
        • 2009 August transcripts
        • 2009 September transcripts
        • 2009 October transcripts
        • 2009 November transcripts
        • 2009 December transcripts
      • 2008 transcripts
        • 2008 January transcripts
        • 2008 February transcripts
        • 2008 March transcripts
        • 2008 April transcripts
        • 2008 May transcripts
        • 2008 June transcripts
        • 2008 July transcripts
        • 2008 August transcripts
        • 2008 September transcripts
        • 2008 October transcripts
        • 2008 November transcripts
        • 2008 December transcripts
      • 2007 transcripts
        • 2007 January transcripts
        • 2007 February transcripts
        • 2007 March transcripts
        • 2007 April transcripts
        • 2007 May transcripts
        • 2007 June transcripts
        • 2007 July transcripts
        • 2007 August transcripts
        • 2007 September transcripts
        • 2007 October transcripts
        • 2007 November transcripts
        • 2007 December transcripts
      • 2006 transcripts
        • 2006 January transcripts
        • 2006 February transcripts
        • 2006 March transcripts
        • 2006 April transcripts
        • 2006 May transcripts
        • 2006 June transcripts
        • 2006 July transcripts
        • 2006 August transcripts
        • 2006 September transcripts
        • 2006 October transcripts
        • 2006 November transcripts
        • 2006 December transcripts
      • 2005 transcripts
        • 2005 January transcripts
        • 2005 February transcripts
        • 2005 March transcripts
        • 2005 April transcripts
        • 2005 May transcripts
        • 2005 June transcripts
        • 2005 July transcripts
        • 2005 August transcripts
        • 2005 September transcripts
        • 2005 October transcripts
        • 2005 November transcripts
        • 2005 December transcripts
      • 2004 transcripts
        • 2004 January transcripts
        • 2004 February transcripts
        • 2004 March transcripts
        • 2004 April transcripts
        • 2004 May transcripts
        • 2004 June transcripts
        • 2004 July transcripts
        • 2004 August transcripts
        • 2004 September transcripts
        • 2004 October transcripts
        • 2004 November transcripts
        • 2004 December transcripts
      • 2003 transcripts
        • 2003 January transcripts
        • 2003 February transcripts
        • 2003 March transcripts
        • 2003 April transcripts
        • 2003 May transcripts
        • 2003 June transcripts
        • 2003 July transcripts
        • 2003 August transcripts
        • 2003 September transcripts
        • 2003 October transcripts
        • 2003 November transcripts
        • 2003 December transcripts
      • 2002 transcripts
        • 2002 January transcripts
        • 2002 February transcripts
        • 2002 March transcripts
        • 2002 April transcripts
        • 2002 May transcripts
        • 2002 June transcripts
        • 2002 July transcripts
        • 2002 August transcripts
        • 2002 September transcripts
        • 2002 October transcripts
        • 2002 November transcripts
        • 2002 December transcripts
      • 2001 transcripts
        • 2001 January transcripts
        • 2001 February transcripts
        • 2001 March transcripts
        • 2001 April transcripts
        • 2001 May transcripts
        • 2001 June transcripts
        • 2001 July transcripts
        • 2001 August transcripts
        • 2001 September transcripts
        • 2001 October transcripts
        • 2001 November transcripts
        • 2001 December transcripts
      • 2000 transcripts
        • 2000 September transcripts
        • 2000 October transcripts
        • 2000 November transcripts
        • 2000 December transcripts
      • Ceremonial sittings transcripts
    • Court reviews
      • 2021 completed court reviews
      • 2020 completed court reviews
      • 2019 completed court reviews
      • 2018 completed court reviews
      • 2017 completed court reviews
      • 2016 completed court reviews
      • 2015 completed court reviews
      • 2014 completed court reviews
      • 2013 completed court reviews
      • 2012 completed court reviews
    • Historical cases
      • Loaded rates in agreements case
      • MFESB & UFUA proposed enterprise agreement
        • Correspondence
        • Submissions
      • Enterprise agreements – Amending Act
      • CFMEU, MUA & TCFUA proposed amalgamation
      • SDA applications for termination of Subway agreements
      • SDA application for termination of Pizza Haven agreement
      • Coles enterprise agreement termination case 2017
      • Ambulance Victoria Work Value Case 2016
        • Applications
        • Correspondence
        • Decisions & statements
        • Exhibits
        • Notices of listing & directions
        • Submissions
        • Transcripts
        • Witness statements
      • Equal Remuneration Case 2010-12
        • Applications
        • Decisions & statements
        • Draft orders
        • Timetable
        • Submissions
        • Correspondence
        • Site inspections
        • Notices of listing
        • Transcript
        • Exhibits
        • Legislation
      • Wages & Allowances Review 2008
      • Wages & Allowances Review 2007
      • Wages & Allowances Review 2006
      • Safety Net Review 2005
      • Family Provisions Case 2003–05
      • Safety Net Review 2004
      • Redundancy Case 2002–04
      • Safety Net Review 2003
      • Safety Net Review 2002
      • Common rule awards in Victoria
        • Full Bench case – Common rule awards in Victoria
  • Registered organisations
    • Fact sheets, templates & webinars
    • Find registered organisations
    • Find State-recognised associations
      • Recognised State-registered associations
    • Registration
      • Amalgamating & deregistering organisations
    • Running a registered organisation
      • Organisations' rules
    • Entry permits
      • Who can hold an entry permit?
      • Using a permit
      • Check an entry permit
      • Apply for a Fair Work entry permit
      • Apply for a Work Health & Safety (WHS) entry permit
      • Right of entry training
      • Disputes about entry
      • Expiry & return of entry permits
    • Industrial action
    • Gazette notices
    • Lodgment
  • Resources
    • Online lodgment
    • Forms
      • Unfair dismissal application
    • Where to get legal help
      • Workplace Advice Service
      • Do I need to be represented?
    • Research
      • Annual wage review research
        • Draft determinations for expense-related allowances
        • Previous research
      • Anti-bullying research
      • Australian workplace relations study
        • AWRS Conference 2015
        • AWRS data centre
          • Online analysis via Tableau dashboards
            • Labour costs analysis
            • Wage setting analysis
            • Workforce profile analysis
          • Online analysis via the Australian Data Archive
          • AWRS confidentialised unit record files
        • AWRS technical notes
          • Research design & process
            • Population: national system employers & employees
            • Units of analysis
          • Sample information
            • Sample design
            • Sample frame
            • Survey weights
            • Sample characteristics
          • AWRS glossary
        • First Findings Report
          • Acknowledgements
          • 1. Introduction
          • 2. Overview of the AWRS sample
            • Key characteristics of AWRS enterprises
            • Key employee characteristics
          • 3. Enterprise operations & indicators of performance
            • Structure
            • Market conditions & performance of AWRS enterprises
            • Financial performance indicators
            • Measurements of labour costs & labour productivity
          • 4. Employment practices
            • Workforce profile
            • Industrial instrument coverage & reasons for use
            • Workforce management practices
              • Operating practices & organisation of work
              • Structure & hierarchy across the workforce
              • Development & progression practices
              • Employee engagement practices
              • Flexible working practices
          • 5. Wage-setting & outcomes
            • Incidence of different methods of setting pay
              • Incidence of National Minimum Wage use
              • Incidence of junior rates use
              • Use of performance-based payments
            • Wage increases
            • Wage-setting outcomes
          • 6. Employee experiences
            • Job satisfaction of employees
            • Key drivers of job satisfaction
            • Career development & opportunities
            • Preferences for more hours
            • Future intentions of employees in the next 12 months
          • List of tables & figures
      • Awards research
      • Pay equity research
      • Promoting productive enterprise agreements project
      • Research community
    • Workplace Relations Education Series
      • Mock hearings
      • Lectures
      • Invited papers
      • 2020 Employment law moot
        • Competition rules
    • Benchbooks
      • How to use the benchbooks
      • Anti-bullying benchbook
      • Enterprise agreements benchbook
      • General protections benchbook
      • Industrial action benchbook
      • Jobkeeper disputes benchbook
      • Unfair dismissals benchbook
    • Fact sheets, guides & videos
      • Guide – Applying for a take-home pay order
      • Guide – Declarations and statutory declarations
    • Practice notes
      • Appeal proceedings
      • Discontinuing matters
      • Fair hearings
      • Lawyers & paid agents
      • Orders to attend & orders to produce
      • Requests to appear remotely
      • Unfair dismissal proceedings
    • Resources in other languages
      • Other languages – by document
    • Case studies
    • Quarterly practitioner updates
      • Summer 2021
      • Spring 2020
      • Winter 2020
      • Autumn 2020
      • Summer 2020
      • Spring 2019
      • Winter 2019
      • Autumn 2019
      • Summer 2019
      • Spring 2018
      • Winter 2018
      • Autumn 2018
      • Summer 2018
      • Spring 2017
      • Winter 2017
      • Autumn 2017
      • Summer 2016
      • Spring 2016
      • Winter 2016
      • Autumn 2016
      • Summer 2015
      • Spring 2015
      • Winter 2015
      • Autumn 2015
    • Related sites
  • Termination of employment
    • Unfair dismissal
      • What is the process for unfair dismissal claims?
      • Unfair dismissal eligibility quiz
      • About conciliation
      • About hearings & conferences
      • Remedies, results & outcomes
        • Calculating compensation
      • Where to get help for unfair dismissal
    • General protections dismissal
      • What is the process for general protections dismissal applications?
      • Remedies
      • Where to get help for general protections
      • General protections – Am I eligible?
    • Unlawful termination
    • How the Commission works
  • Disputes at work
    • Fairness in the workplace
      • Rights & obligations
      • Resolving issues at the workplace
      • Business transfers, shutdowns & closures
    • Resolving issues at the Commission
      • Workplace determinations
    • Cooperative Workplaces program
      • Interest-based approaches
      • Interest-based bargaining
      • Interest-based consultation
      • Interest-based problem-solving
    • JobKeeper disputes
    • General protections (unlawful actions)
    • Anti-bullying
      • Where to get help about bullying
      • Who can apply?
      • What is the process?
      • Anti-bullying – Am I eligible to apply?
      • Forms & fees
      • Glossary
    • Industrial action
      • Taking industrial action
      • Protected action ballots
        • Ballot results 2021
        • Ballot results 2020
        • Ballot results 2019
        • Ballot results 2018
        • Ballot results 2017
        • Ballot results 2016
        • Ballot results 2015
        • Ballot results 2014
        • Ballot results 2013
        • Ballot results 2012
        • Ballot results 2011
        • Ballot results 2010
        • Ballot results 2009
        • Ballot results 2008
        • Ballot results 2007
        • Ballot results 2006
    • Awards & enterprise agreements disputes
      • Interpret or enforce an agreement
      • Interpret or enforce an award
    • Disputes about entry
    • How the Commission works
      • Resolving disputes
      • Lodge an application
        • Online Lodgment Service
      • Respond to an application
      • Enforce a decision or order
      • Appeal a decision or order
        • About appeals
        • Appeal benches
      • Commission offices
        • Australian Capital Territory
        • New South Wales
        • Northern Territory
        • Queensland
        • South Australia
        • Tasmania
        • Victoria
        • Western Australia
      • Conduct & behaviour
      • Hearings & conferences
        • Adelaide hearings
        • Brisbane hearings
        • Canberra hearings
        • Darwin hearings
        • Hobart hearings
        • Melbourne hearings
        • Perth hearings
        • Sydney hearings
        • Regional hearings
        • About hearings & conferences
        • Appeal hearing dates
      • Video tour of the Commission
        • What is the Fair Work Commission?

Downloads

  • Appeal proceedings
  • Appeal proceedings
  • Attachment 1 – Form of submissions
  • Attachment 1 – Form of submissions

Footer

  • Site map
  • Legal
  • Copyright
  • Accessibility

Coronavirus (COVID-19) information